I wrote about JR line in downtown Osaka on previous post. Now I would like to share the information about the transfer among Osaka, Kyoto and Kobe. Kyoto is “Must-See” spot in Japan. And some of you think about Osaka and Kobe too. Kyoto is only 30 minutes away from Osaka by Special Rapid train on JR line. Kobe is closer than Kyoto from Osaka. It is only 20 minutes from Osaka. But JR line and several private railway lines run side by side. Sometimes these railway systems confuse you. I will explain about this railway system later on this post. Anyway if you want to buy a single ticket or save your Japan Rail Pass while you stay in Osaka/Kyoto/Kobe, you have a choice.
I would like to explain about JR line and private railway companies on this post. You may find how to choose the railways among Kyoto, Osaka and Kobe.
Private Railways in Osaka, Kyoto and Kobe
View Kyoto-Osaka-Kobe in a larger map
The above map shows you all railway lines among Osaka, Kyoto and Kobe. I would like to explain about each private lines. Hankyu Railway and Hanshin Railway depart from Umeda in Osaka. As you probably know, Umeda station is same place as JR Osaka station. Please learn more about Osaka at the post, How to use Japan Rail Pass in downtown Osaka.
Hankyu Railway connect Osaka with Kyoto, Kobe and Takarazuka (宝塚). The trains depart from Umeda (梅田) in Osaka and take you to Kawaramachi (河原町), Karasuma (烏丸), Omiya (大宮) and Arashiyama (嵐山) in Kyoto, and Sannomiya (三宮) in Kobe. Even though you need to change the train at Katsura () where is the junction of to Kawaramachia and to Arashiyama, this line is most convenient way to get Arashiyama.
If you want to use this line from Kyoto to Kobe, you need to change the train because they don’t have any scheduled direct train from Kyoto to Kobe. You need to change the train at Juso (十三) or Umeda. Juso is the junction of Kobe line, Kyoto line, and Takarazuka line. This station is only two stations away from Umeda. But the direct trains from Umeda, Sannnomiya and Takarazuka to Arashiyama are operated in Spring cherry blossom and Autumn color leaves peak season.
Hankyu Railway operates several kinds of trains, like limited express, express, local. But you don’t need to pay any surcharge to take any trains on Hankyu. Even Limited Express is same types of service as Special Rapid Service on Japan Railway. The time required and the fare on major sections are the following:
- Umeda / Sannomiya — 27 minutes / 310 yen
- Umeda / Kawaramachi — 43 minutes / 390 yen
- Umeda / Arashiyama — 45 minutes / 390 yen
Hanshin Electric Railway connect Osaka with Kobe. But Hanshin have two terminals at two biggest downtown core in Osaka, Umeda and Namba (難波), and take you to Sannomiya and Motomachi (元町) in Kobe. And also Hanshin Railway line is connected with Kobe Kosoku Railway line (神戸高速鉄道) and Sanyo Electric Railway line (山陽電鉄) at Motomachi in Kobe, and Kintetsu Railway line (近鉄) at Namba in Osaka. Some of the trains go through Akashi and Himeji via Kobe Kosoku Railway line and Sanyo Electric Railway line, and Nara via Kintetsu Railway Nara line. Major direct train services are the following:
- Umeda – Sannomiya – Motomachi – Akashi – Himeji
- Nara – Namba – Amagasaki – Sannomiya – Motomachi
The direct train service on the different lines is not very rare in Japan. But this kind of train network confuses the travellers. Anyway please see the following link about Hanshin Railway network.
Hanshin Electric Railway operates several kinds of trains, like limited express, express, local. But you don’t need to pay any surcharge to take any trains on Hankyu. Even Limited Express is same types of service as Special Rapid Service on Japan Railway. The time required and the fare on major sections are the following:
- Umeda / Sannomiya — 31 minutes / 310 yen
- Namba / Sannomiya — 47 minutes / 400 yen
This line starts from Yodoyabashi (淀屋橋) and Nakanoshima (中ノ島) in downtown Osaka to Gion-Shijo (祇園四条) and Sanjo (三条) in Kyoto via Kyobashi (京橋). If you want to go to Higashiyama area in Kyoto (Kiyomizudera temple, Yasaka Jinja shrine, Philosopher’s Walk), most of the spots are on the route of Keihan Railway.
And also Keihan Railway’s limited express train is operated by double decker passenger’s car. You can take this express train and any other trains without any surcharge. This limited express train is same service as Special Rapid Service on Japan Railway as well. The time required and the fare on major sections are the following:
- Yodoyabashi / Gion-Shijo or Sanjo — 50 minutes / 400 yen
- Kyobashi / Gion-Shijo or Sanjo — 43 minutes / 400 yen
If you use Japan Rail Pass or JR West Rail Pass, of course, try to use Japan Railway line as much as you can. You may use these following trains.
This rapid service gives you same type of service as other private company’s limited express service. Most of this train services are operated between Yasu and Himeji via Kyoto, Osaka and Sannomiya. Especially if you need a fast direct transfer to Kyoto from Kobe, this service is the fastest. The time required and the fare on major sections are the following:
- Osaka / Sannomiya — 22 minutes / 390 yen
- Osaka / Kyoto — 28 minutes / 540 yen
- Sannomiya / Kyoto — 50 minutes / 1050 yen
- Osaka / Arashiyama — 50-55 minutes / 950 yen
If you need more information about Special Rapid Service, please refer this post, Special Rapid Service.
View Downtown Kobe in a larger map
You may think about taking Shinkansen. It connects Shin-Osaka with Kyoto in 13 minutes and Shin-Osaka with Shin-Kobe in 15 minutes. Yes, this is so fast. But Shin-Osaka is one station away from Osaka (Umeda). So you need to spend 5 minutes to get Shin-Osaka from Osaka by local train. And you spend another 10 to 15 minutes to change the train. So it may be slower than Special Rapid Service. Shin-Kobe is not located in downtown Kobe. It is one station away from Sannomiya by Kobe city subway. It takes two minutes from Sannomiya to Shin-Kobe and costs 200 yen. It is same story as Osaka-Kyoto transfer. You may spend 10 minutes to change the train at Shin-Kobe and another time for transfer from Osaka to Shin-Osaka. I cannot find any reason take Shinkansen from Osaka to Kobe.
If you need transfer from Kobe to Kyoto, Shinkansen may be considerable. The direct service between Kyoto and Shin-Kobe is not operated very often. But if you can find it, it takes 30 minutes to get Shin-Kobe from Kyoto. You spend 10 to 15 minutes to get a subway in Kobe. It is still 10 minutes faster than Special Rapid Service.
View Kyoto-Osaka-Kobe in a larger map
How to choose the lines and trains to Kyoto from Osaka
Departure station in Osaka
Where are you going to stay in Osaka? If you will stay in Umeda area, Hankyu and Japan Railway may be your choice. If you stay near Yodoyabashi, Tenmabashi or Kyobashi, Keihan is more accessible. If you stay in Namba or other location in Osaka, you need to take subway line or JR Osaka loop line anyway. Think about arrival station in Kyoto.
View Kyoto-Osaka-Kobe in a larger map
Arrival station in Kyoto
Which part of Kyoto do you want to go? Japan Railway is the fastest way to get Kyoto.
Japan Railway Osaka – Kyoto 28 minutes
Hankyu Umeda – Kawaramachi 43 minutes
Keihan Yodoyamabashi – Gion-Shijo 50 minutes
But Kyoto station is not tourist friendly location. You need to take a bus or subway to get most of popular spots, like Kinkakuji temple, Kiyomizudera temple, Yasaka Jinja shrine. Only Arashiyama and Nijo castle is accessible by Japan Railway. Please read the post, How to use Japan Rail Pass in Kyoto. If you are not Japan Rail Pass user, do not take Japan Railway.
If you want to go to Higashiyama or Gion, such as Kiyomizudera temple, Yasaka Jinja shrine, Philosopher’s Walk, Hankyu Railway and Keihan Railway are more convenient than Japan Railway. If you want to go to Arashiayama, you can use Japan Railway. But Hankyu Railway is faster and cheaper.
If you are looking for information about all trains in Kyoto, please refer the post, Guide to take trains in Kyoto. How to choose the best route by train to get the major spots?.
How to choose the lines and trains to Kobe from Osaka
Departure station in Osaka
You have two options, Umeda/JR Osaka or Namba. If you stay around Umeda area, you can choose from Japan Railway, Hankyu or Hanshin. Hankyu and Hanshin are cheaper than Japan Railway. But Japan Railway is the fastest.
If you will stay in Namba area, Hanshin is only and the best choice
Arrival station in Kobe
Which part of Kobe do you want to go? You can go anywhere in Kobe by Japan Railway and Hanshin Electric Railway. Most of trains of Hankyu Railway go to Sannomiya only. If you are looking for the transfer to other area in Kobe, think about JR or Hanshin.
But Kobe is smaller than Kyoto. So it is not much different among JR, Hanshin and Hankyu.
How to choose the lines and trains between Kobe and Kyoto
Only Japan Railway’s Special Rapid Service give you direct transfer. It is the fastest and maybe faster than even Shinkansen. But as I mentioned to you above, JR Kyoto station is not good location for the tourists. On the other hand, Hankyu Railway can take you to Kyoto from Kobe. They don’t have any scheduled train on this section. But Kawaramachi station is located near Gion and Higashiyama. Let’s compare JR and Hankyu.
Sannomiya / JR Kyoto — 50 minutes / 1050 yen
Sannomiya / Hankyu Kawaramachi — 65 minutes (change the trains at Juso) / 600 yen
Hankyu is slower, but cheaper. And also we need to think about the location in Kyoto. If you take JR, you need to take a bus or subway to get Gion. You may spend another 15-20 minutes get there from JR Kyoto station. So if you want to go to Gion Higashiyama area, Hankyu is better choice. If you go to Arashiyama in Kyoto, it is same story. Hankyu is better as well.
Tokyo Disney Resort
Sapporo Hakodate Furano, Biei Kushiro Abashiri, Shiretoko
Sendai Hakone Yokohama Kusatsu Kawaguchiko (Fuji) Karuizawa Nagano Nagoya Kanazawa Takayama Shirakawago
Kyoto (Kyoto station Gion, Higashiyama Arashiyama )
Osaka (JR Osaka, Umeda Shin-Osaka Namba, Shinsaibashi USJ Kansai airport )
Kobe, Arima Kinosaki Hiroshima Miyajima
Hakata Nagasaki Beppu Yufuin
You may also like these posts:
210 Comments to “How to transfer among Kyoto, Osaka and Kobe. Compare Japan Railway and private lines”
- Commuting on an early train ride from Osaka to Kyoto
- Osaka to Kyoto (An early train ride) | WeeJu Lee